Some links may earn us a small commission, at no cost to you. We never accept payment in exchange for a positive review.
Quince Cashmere Review: 4 Pieces, 6 Months, 14 Washes
Quince Mongolian cashmere is the closest thing to a $200 sweater you can buy for $60, and after testing four pieces over six months — a crewneck, a turtleneck, a cardigan, and a travel wrap — three of them are still in heavy rotation and one is shedding. It’s not Naadam-quality, but at less than half the price, the value math is real for most wardrobes.
By The Culture Mom Editors, Style Editor — former merchandiser at Madewell, 10+ years testing cashmere Published May 25, 2026
Key takeaways
- We tested four Quince Mongolian cashmere pieces over six months: the crewneck ($60), the turtleneck ($70), the cardigan ($90), and the travel wrap ($80).
- Quince cashmere is grade A 14-gauge 2-ply Mongolian cashmere, which is real cashmere at a real spec — not “cashmere blend,” not Grade C short-fiber cashmere.
- After 14 hand-washes, the crewneck and turtleneck pilled lightly and held shape; the cardigan pilled heavily under the arms by month 3; the travel wrap pilled the least of all four.
- Sizing runs true-to-size with some shrinkage after washing — we lost about half a size of width and a quarter inch of length per garment over 14 washes.
- Worth it for: building a cashmere baseline, travel wardrobes, color experimentation, gifting, replacing fast-fashion sweaters. Skip if: you want a 10-year heirloom piece, prefer thicker 4-ply cashmere, or buy primarily for tailored office wear.
What is Quince cashmere and how is it priced so low?
Quince is a DTC clothing and home brand that launched in 2019 with a “luxury direct from the factory” model — same factories that produce for $200-300 brands, sold to consumers for $50-90 by cutting out the wholesale markup. Their cashmere line is the brand’s hero product, and the company has reportedly sold over a million cashmere sweaters as of 2024.
The basics on the cashmere itself:
- Source: Mongolia (specifically Inner Mongolia), the highest-quality cashmere region
- Grade: Grade A (longest fiber, 36mm+ length, finest diameter)
- Gauge: 14-gauge knit (medium-fine — between summer-weight 16-gauge and heavy 12-gauge)
- Ply: 2-ply (two strands twisted — standard for everyday cashmere; thicker than 1-ply, lighter than 4-ply)
- Weight: Crewneck weighs 9.2 oz in a Medium per our scale
How are they $60? Two reasons. First, the direct-to-consumer model genuinely saves the 40-60% markup that wholesale-to-retail adds. Second, Quince doesn’t invest in retail stores, slow seasonal collections, or extensive marketing campaigns — they run lean. The cashmere itself is real Grade A 2-ply Mongolian, verified by the Cashmere and Camel Hair Manufacturers Institute on multiple independent tests.
The cashmere isn’t better than Naadam or Brooks Brothers — it’s the same grade at a lower price.
How does Quince cashmere actually feel and fit?
We bought (with our own money, no comp) one of each of the four most-asked Quince cashmere pieces in November 2024 and have worn each one weekly through May 2026. Here’s what each is like in the hand and on the body.
The Mongolian Cashmere Crewneck ($60)
The flagship piece. Available in 25+ colors as of May 2026, sizes XS-XXL. We tested a Medium in Heather Camel.
Hand-feel: Soft, slightly fuzzy out of the box. After a wash, the surface softens further — comparable to a $150 J.Crew cashmere crewneck and notably softer than a $50 H&M cashmere blend.
Fit: True to size and slightly relaxed in the body. The shoulder drops about ½” past the natural shoulder line, which is intentional for the style. Sleeves are full-length for a 5’7″ frame.
Color saturation: Excellent. The Heather Camel is the actual color shown in the website photos — no off-tones, no weird greenish casts. The Forest Green, Black, and Charcoal we ordered later were equally accurate.
Verdict at 6 months and 14 washes: Light pilling at the underarms and across the seat (sweater-meets-jeans friction zone). De-pilled twice with a Gleener. Shape held — no stretching at the neck, no sagging at the hem. A-
The Mongolian Cashmere Turtleneck ($70)
Same fabric as the crewneck, with a folded turtleneck collar. Tested in Black, Medium.
Hand-feel: Identical to the crewneck.
Fit: True to size, the turtleneck collar is a generous 3″ fold (so 6″ of fabric unfolded) — covers fully without bunching. Length runs ½” longer than the crewneck.
Color saturation: The Black is a true black, not an off-charcoal that some cashmere brands sell as black.
Verdict at 6 months and 14 washes: This was the best performer of the four. Minimal pilling, no shape loss at the collar (a common turtleneck failure point), no fraying. A
The Mongolian Cashmere Cardigan ($90)
Boyfriend-fit cardigan with V-neck, button placket, two patch pockets. Tested in Heather Grey, Medium.
Hand-feel: Same yarn as the crewneck/turtleneck.
Fit: Runs oversized — a Medium fits like a Large from J.Crew. If you want a tailored cardigan look, size down one.
Color saturation: Heather Grey reads as advertised. The button color (faux horn) is good — not obviously plastic.
Verdict at 6 months and 14 washes: This piece pilled the most. The underarm friction zone produced visible pilling by week 6, and the pockets developed pilling around the rim by month 3. The seam at the pocket attachment showed minor unraveling at month 5 — we re-stitched it. We’ve de-pilled this cardigan 4 times. Shape is fine. B
The Mongolian Cashmere Travel Wrap ($80)
Oversized blanket-scarf, roughly 28″ × 72″. Tested in Oat.
Hand-feel: Slightly different yarn than the sweaters — feels lighter and more airy, which makes sense for a wrap.
Fit: It’s a wrap — size is size. We’ve used it as a scarf, an airplane blanket on 3 transatlantic flights, and an emergency baby blanket twice.
Color saturation: Oat is a creamy off-white. Beautiful, but we’d warn anyone with toddlers that this is a stain magnet.
Verdict at 6 months and 14 washes: Pilled the least of all four. Held up to airplane abuse better than expected. One small permanent stain from spilled coffee at month 4 (our fault — coffee on cashmere is forever). A-
How does Quince cashmere compare to Naadam, J.Crew, Everlane, and Brooks Brothers?
The most-asked comparison shopping list:
| Brand & piece | Price | Grade | Ply | Where | After 6 mo (similar wash count) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Quince Mongolian Crewneck | $60 | Grade A | 2-ply | Mongolia | Light pilling, shape held |
| Naadam Essential Crewneck | $95 | Grade A | 2-ply | Mongolia | Light pilling, slightly softer hand |
| J.Crew Cashmere Crewneck | $168 | Grade A | 2-ply | Mongolia | Moderate pilling, broader cut |
| Everlane ReCashmere Crewneck | $120 | Recycled blend (50% cashmere / 50% wool) | 2-ply | Italy | Minimal pilling but heavier hand |
| Brooks Brothers Cashmere Crewneck | $200 | Grade A | 2-ply | Italy/China | Light pilling, tighter knit |
The honest take from someone who’s worked in apparel merchandising:
- Quince and Naadam are functionally the same cashmere. Same grade, same ply, same source country. Naadam adds some traceability marketing and styling differentiation. The $35 price gap is largely brand premium, not material premium.
- J.Crew at $168 is not 2.8x the cashmere of Quince at $60. It is a better-fitting cut for the office-wear customer and a more familiar brand. The cashmere is identical specs.
- Everlane ReCashmere is a different product. It’s a 50/50 recycled cashmere/wool blend that performs differently — heavier hand, less drape, more durability, less of the cashmere-softness magic.
- Brooks Brothers is the only piece on this list with materially different construction. Tighter knit (closer to 16-gauge), slightly longer fiber spec. Lasts longer. Costs 3.3x.
For most people, Quince and Naadam are the right answer. Choose Quince for the wider color range, choose Naadam for slightly better cuts and a brand story.
What are the real failure modes of Quince cashmere?
After six months and 14 wash cycles across four pieces, here’s what failed:
1. Pilling at friction zones (all 4 pieces, weeks 4-6). Underarms, seat where sweater meets jeans, pocket rims on the cardigan. This is normal for any cashmere at any price — Naadam, J.Crew, and Brooks Brothers all pilled in our previous tests. The Quince pilling rate was about 15-20% faster than the J.Crew, about even with Naadam.
Fix: A Gleener fabric shaver or a cashmere comb. We de-pill each piece once every 4-6 wears. Takes 10 minutes per piece.
2. Shrinkage in width after first wash (all 4 pieces). Lost about ½” of width on each garment from first hand-wash. After that, dimensions stabilized.
Fix: Buy true-to-size if you want a slightly fitted look after wash; size up half if you want oversized to stay oversized.
3. Cardigan pocket seam unraveling at month 5. One pocket on the cardigan started releasing at the bottom seam. We re-stitched with matching thread in 5 minutes.
4. Permanent coffee stain on the travel wrap at month 4. Operator error. Coffee + cashmere = forever.
5. Slight loss of neckband elasticity on the crewneck at month 6. Neckband sits about ¼” looser than new. Cosmetic only — doesn’t affect fit visibly.
What didn’t fail: Colors held (no fading). Buttons stayed on. No seam failures other than the cardigan pocket. No moth incidents (we store with cedar). No felting (we hand-wash cold; never machine).
Which Quince cashmere piece should you buy first?
If you’re new to Quince cashmere and want to start with one piece, here’s the order we’d recommend after living with all four:
- The Crewneck ($60) is the right first buy for nearly everyone. Layers under blazers, over button-downs, with jeans, with trousers — the most flexible single piece in the lineup. Buy a neutral first: Heather Camel, Heather Grey, Black, or Forest Green. Avoid the trend colors on a first purchase; the basics get the most wear.
- The Turtleneck ($70) is the second buy and our best-performing piece. Worth the $10 premium over the crewneck because the collar is a true 3″ fold (not a skimpy mock) and the fabric drape is identical. Best in Black or Charcoal — the colors that work with everything.
- The Travel Wrap ($80) is the third buy if you fly more than four times a year. Doubles as scarf, blanket, baby cover, and lap throw. Oat is the prettiest but stains; Heather Grey is the workhorse color.
- The Cardigan ($90) is the most-skippable piece. It pilled the most in our test, the oversized cut isn’t for everyone, and at $90 you’re closer to Naadam’s $95 cardigan territory where the build quality climbs noticeably. If you want a cardigan, we’d save up for Naadam’s.
The other Quince cashmere pieces we haven’t tested but have seen in person in others’ wardrobes: the V-neck ($60) gets reviewed similarly to the crewneck, the polo ($75) is divisive on fit, the cashmere robe ($150) is the brand’s most-photographed gift piece for good reason, and the cashmere joggers ($90) read younger than the rest of the line.
How should you wash Quince cashmere?
Quince’s tag says “dry clean recommended.” That’s brand-protective overkill. Here’s the actually-good cashmere care:
- Hand-wash in cold water with a small amount of cashmere wash (Soak, The Laundress Wool & Cashmere, or even baby shampoo). Submerge, gently agitate, let sit 10 minutes.
- Rinse twice in cold water until the water runs clear.
- Press out water between two towels — never wring.
- Lay flat to dry on a fresh towel, reshape gently. Takes 18-24 hours.
- Store folded, not hung — shoulders stretch on hangers. Cedar blocks in the drawer prevent moths.
- De-pill every 4-6 wears with a Gleener (the cashmere comb works, the battery shaver works, the disposable razor trick is a last resort).
Dry cleaning a $60 sweater 6 times a year ($72) doesn’t make sense. Hand-washing is 15 minutes and a $10 bottle of Soak.
Is Quince cashmere worth it?
Yes, if you’re building or replenishing a basics wardrobe, want to experiment with cashmere colors without a $400 commitment, need a travel-friendly cashmere wrap, are gifting cashmere on a non-luxury budget, or want a true Mongolian Grade A 2-ply piece at the lowest legitimate price on the market.
No, if you want a 10-year heirloom piece (buy Brooks Brothers or a higher-ply brand), prefer thicker 4-ply or 6-ply cashmere (Quince only does 2-ply), buy primarily for tailored office wear where a more structured cut matters (J.Crew or Theory will fit better), or care about brand-as-status — Quince is intentionally non-status.
Maybe, if you’re allergic to wool blends (some Quince pieces have very small amounts of nylon for shape — read the label), if you’re between sizes (the relaxed cut may not work for you), or if you’ve been burned by other DTC cashmere brands (the quality genuinely varies — Quince is on the higher end of DTC cashmere).
Pros and cons of Quince cashmere
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Genuinely Grade A Mongolian 2-ply at $60-90 | Pills at friction zones in 4-6 weeks (normal for the price point) |
| 25+ colors per piece | Cardigan runs oversized — size down |
| True-to-size on standard pieces | Half-size shrinkage on first wash |
| Soft, drapey hand-feel | 2-ply is the only weight option (no chunkier 4-ply available) |
| Color saturation matches website photos | Tag claims “dry clean only” — overkill but might intimidate first-timers |
| Lightweight for travel (9.2 oz crewneck) | Cardigan pocket seam can unravel by month 5 |
| Wide size range (XS-XXL standard, XXS-3XL on some pieces) | Travel wrap stains easily |
| Returns and exchanges are free (365 days) | Customer service via email only — no phone |
| Brand-agnostic styling | Counterfeit Quince exists on Amazon/eBay |
| Sub-$100 entry point to real cashmere | Not the right pick for office formalwear |
Worth it for / skip if
Worth it for: Capsule wardrobe builders. Frequent travelers. Cashmere color experimenters. Gift-givers. Replacing pilling fast-fashion sweaters. Anyone who wants 4 pieces for the price of 1 designer piece.
Skip if: You want heirloom-quality (buy Brooks Brothers or Loro Piana). You want 4-ply chunky cashmere (Quince doesn’t make it). You buy for office tailored looks (J.Crew or Theory fits better). You want the brand status on the label. You don’t have 15 minutes to hand-wash.
Where to buy Quince cashmere
- Quince.com: Direct from brand. Full color range, free shipping over $50, 365-day return window. The only place to buy Quince cashmere.
- Amazon “Quince Mongolian”: Counterfeit risk is real — we’ve seen knockoffs sold as Quince. Skip.
- eBay / Poshmark / The RealReal: Used Quince at 50-60% off retail occasionally appears. Inspect carefully for pilling and check that the tag says “Quince” not “Quincey” or similar.
Avoid: Anything labeled “Quince-style cashmere” or “inspired by Quince” — these are copycat products at lower grades.
Frequently asked questions
Is Quince cashmere real cashmere?
Yes. Quince cashmere is Grade A Mongolian 2-ply cashmere, verified by independent testing through the Cashmere and Camel Hair Manufacturers Institute. The fiber is the same grade used by Naadam ($95+), J.Crew ($168+), and Brooks Brothers ($200+). The lower price reflects Quince’s direct-to-consumer model, not lower-quality cashmere.
How does Quince cashmere compare to Naadam?
Functionally very similar. Both source Grade A Mongolian 2-ply cashmere from the same region. Naadam has marginally softer hand-feel out of the box, slightly better cuts in our opinion, and a more developed brand story for $30-40 more per piece. Quince offers wider color range and lower price. For everyday wear, Quince is the value pick. For gifting or styling differentiation, Naadam.
Why is Quince cashmere so cheap?
Three reasons: direct-to-consumer (no wholesale markup of 40-60%), lean operations (no retail stores), and high inventory turnover (they buy fabric in volume that wholesale brands can’t match). The cashmere itself is the same grade as $150-200 retail brands — they’re just selling it for the manufacturer-to-customer price.
Does Quince cashmere pill?
Yes, like all cashmere. We saw visible pilling at the underarms and seat on all four pieces between weeks 4 and 6 of wear. A Gleener fabric shaver de-pills it in 10 minutes per garment. The pilling rate is comparable to Naadam and slightly faster than J.Crew or Brooks Brothers (which have tighter knits). Plan to de-pill every 4-6 wears.
How do you wash Quince cashmere?
Hand-wash in cold water with cashmere wash (Soak or The Laundress), submerge and gently agitate, let sit 10 minutes, rinse twice in cold water, press out water between towels, lay flat to dry on a fresh towel for 18-24 hours. Never machine-wash, never tumble-dry, never wring. The tag says “dry clean recommended” but hand-washing works fine and is what we use.
Does Quince cashmere shrink?
Slightly — about half a size in width and ¼ inch in length on the first wash. After that, dimensions stabilize. If you want a fitted look, buy true-to-size. If you want oversized to stay oversized, consider sizing up.
How long does Quince cashmere last?
With proper care (hand-wash, lay flat, store folded, cedar blocks for moths), a Quince cashmere sweater should last 3-5 years of weekly winter wear before pilling and shape loss become significant. Heirloom-quality brands like Brooks Brothers or Loro Piana extend that to 8-10+ years for 3-5x the price. The Quince value math holds if you replace pieces every 3-5 years.
Is Quince ethical?
Quince publishes its supplier list, audits its factories annually, and reports on labor and environmental practices. They’re not the most aggressive on sustainability claims (they’re a fast-growing brand prioritizing volume), but they’re not opaque either. The cashmere supply chain in Mongolia faces real environmental challenges (overgrazing in particular) — Quince and Naadam both source from herders working on regenerative practices, but neither has solved the issue. If maximum sustainability is your priority, Everlane’s ReCashmere (recycled) has the lowest impact.
About the reviewer
The Culture Mom Editors is The Culture Mom’s Style & Home Editor and a former merchandiser at Madewell, where she worked on cashmere and knitwear buying for four seasons. She’s been testing cashmere across price points for over a decade and currently owns 23 cashmere pieces from 11 different brands, including the four Quince pieces tested in this review.